发信人: onlyone (欧灵婉|可不可以让我再), 信区: ASCIIArt
标 题: Re: 梅兰竹菊 by wumi@zixia
发信站: 北大未名站 (2008年06月06日00:19:51 星期五), 转信
思索再三,还是决定说点对前辈不敬的话
在我看来好画有三要:构图、配色、细节
配色就不提了,wumi前辈的细节用汉字的风格问题我也不多言了
咱们就来说说这构图
首先,第一个问题,是单一,兰和竹都有这个毛病,直的叶子,直的杆
一图到底没有什么变化
这个问题的本质我想在于构图时wumi前辈过于在意连贯性
当然还因为构图的空间过小
第二个问题,细节处理还是不到位,有人可能不理解了
但是认真看兰、菊就会查出端倪
这个问题我想....恐怕还是手生
可能是flubber前辈的梅兰竹菊给我留下太深的印象
脑海是尽是用3做梅的神来之笔
对wumi前辈的新作不能产生共鸣,应该是事前带入的原因吧
我写这些不是想打击前辈或是带有藐视的态度
wumi前辈的画在ansiart.org我也是全数拜读
名家点评里有他一讲,细节汉字也是带出了一种风格
说了这么多其实也是本人骨子里的fj
人人都赞,我偏鸡蛋里挑骨头,或许有助于激发更深入的讨论....
【 在 haoyuan (AS07|气象万千) 的大作中提到: 】
: 菊的花瓣就算如此我也画不出来呵呵,
: 梅是公认的很赞的了...
Sender: onlyone Ou Lingwan, can you let me do it again? Message area: ASCIIArt
Title: Re: Plum, Orchid, Bamboo and Chrysanthemum by wumi@zixia
Sending station: Peking University Weiming Station June 6, 2008 00:19:51 Friday, forwarded
After much thought, I decided to say something disrespectful to my seniors.
In my opinion, there are three elements to a good painting: composition, color matching, and details.
I won’t mention the color scheme. I won’t go into details about senior Wumi’s style of using Chinese characters.
Let’s talk about this composition
First of all, the first problem is that it is single. Both orchids and bamboos have this problem. They have straight leaves and straight stems.
There is no change in the picture
I think the essence of this problem is that Wumi-senpai cares too much about coherence when composing the picture.
Of course, it’s also because the composition space is too small.
The second question is that the details are still not handled properly. Some people may not understand it.
But if you look carefully at Lan Ju, you will find out the clues.
I think this question...I'm afraid it's still new to me
Maybe it’s because Flubber-senpai’s Plum, Orchid, Bamboo and Chrysanthemum left a deep impression on me.
My mind is full of magical ideas of using 3 to make plum blossoms.
I can’t resonate with wumi-senpai’s new work. Maybe it’s because I brought it in beforehand.
I am not writing this to criticize my predecessors or have a contemptuous attitude.
I also read all of wumi-senpai’s paintings on ansiart.org
He talks about it in the comments of famous experts. The detailed Chinese characters also bring out a style.
Having said so much, I am actually a fj in my heart.
Everyone likes it, but I'm a bit of a nitpicker, which might help spark a more in-depth discussion....
Mentioned in haoyuan AS07's masterpiece:
: Even so, I can’t draw the chrysanthemum petals haha
: Mei is recognized as being very good...