发信人: daviddvd (0519|HiHigh团@泉| daviddvd.net), 信区: ANSI
标 题: [转载][裁决] DixReves vs FFXeNoN
发信站: 日月光华 (2011年12月27日23:18:18 星期二), 站内信件
【 以下文字转载自 Advice 讨论区 】
【 原文由 dog 所发表 】
【 以下文字转载自 Appeal 讨论区 】
【 原文由 Arbitrator 所发表 】
申 请 人: DixReves
被申请人: FFXeNoN
诉 由:
网友DixReves认为,站长FFXeNoN认定其签名档违规及相关处理不妥。
诉 求:
撤销或减轻处罚。
相关证据:
————————————————————————————————————
1. DixReves的复议申请书;
————————————————————————————————————
2. Complaint版相关文章;
————————————————————————————————————
3. 其它讨论区中DixReves所发表的包含该签名档的文章;
————————————————————————————————————
4. 仲裁组取证信件(不予列出)。
————————————————————————————————————
以上证据均陈列于:Appeal版精华区x-10-7-60
————————————————————————————————————
仲裁依据:
复旦大学日月光华电子公告牌执行办法:条目4.7
6.27
仲裁组讨论:
仲裁组经过调阅相关发文、信件等证据后讨论认为:网友DixReves在被举
报的帖子和其他的一些发文中所使用的签名档,确实存在遮挡引言部分的情况
并且影响了其他网友正常的阅读。站长FFXeNoN 要求其修改签名档后,在知晓
处理决定的情况下未能及时修改, FFXeNoN因此对其封禁登陆权限处罚合理,
并无不当之处。
网友DixReves对该签名档的使用,本身并无恶意,用于签名档的ANSI作品
也具有特殊意义。对于此类情况的签名档,仲裁组建议站务委员会提供申请使
用的可能,并给出相应的使用范围和具体规则,让网友能够最大程度地保留这
些珍贵的原创。
裁决:
驳回DixReves的所有诉求。
本裁决为终审裁决,自公布之日起生效。
日月光华BBS仲裁组
执行仲裁:wf
moonbear
Sato
2011.12.26
--
本裁决为仲裁裁决。
日月光华仲裁组
※ 来源:·日月光华 bbs.fudan.edu.cn·[FROM: 仲裁组]
--
※ 转载:·日月光华 bbs.fudan.edu.cn·[FROM: 114.145.53.*]
--
※ 转载:·日月光华 bbs.fudan.edu.cn·[FROM: 162.105.222.*]
Sender: daviddvd 0519 HiHighgroup@quan daviddvd.net, letter area: ANSI
Title: [Reprint][Judgment] DixReves vs FFXeNoN
Sending site: Sun and Moon Guanghua Tuesday, December 27, 2011 23:18:18, site mail
The following text is reproduced from the Advice discussion forum
Originally published by dog
The following text is reproduced from the Appeal discussion forum
Originally published by Arbitrator
Applicant DixReves
Respondent FFXeNoN
Cause of action
Netizen DixReves believes that the webmaster FFXeNoN determined that his signature file violated the regulations and related handling was inappropriate.
demands
Withdraw or reduce punishment
Relevant evidence
1. DixReves’ application for reconsideration
2. Articles related to the Complaint version
3. Articles containing the signature file published by DixReves in other discussion forums
4. The arbitration panel’s evidence collection letters will not be listed.
The above evidence is displayed in the highlights area of the Appeal edition x 10 7 60
Basis for arbitration
Fudan University Sun Moon Guanghua Electronic Bulletin Board Implementation Measures Item 4.7
6.27
Arbitration panel discussion
After reviewing relevant documents, letters and other evidence, the arbitration panel concluded that netizen Dix Reves was being prosecuted
The signature file used in the newspaper’s posts and some other posts did block the introduction part.
And it affects the normal reading of other netizens. After knowing it, the webmaster FFXeNoN asked him to modify the signature file.
FFXeNoN failed to revise the decision in time, so the penalty for banning login rights was reasonable.
Nothing inappropriate
Netizen DixReves’ use of the signature file is not malicious in itself. ANSI works used for signature files
It also has special significance. For signature documents in such cases, the arbitration panel recommends that the station committee provide the application with
Possibility of use and the corresponding scope of use and specific rules are given so that netizens can retain this information to the greatest extent.
some precious originals
ruling
Dismiss all claims of DixReves
This ruling is final and takes effect from the date of publication.
Sun Moon Guanghua BBS Arbitration Team
Enforce arbitration wf
moonbear
Sato
2011.12.26
This award is an arbitral award
Sun Moon Guanghua Arbitration Group
Source: Sun and Moon Guanghua bbs.fudan.edu.cn [FROM: Arbitration Group]
Reprint: Sun and Moon Guanghua bbs.fudan.edu.cn [FROM: 114.145.53.*]
Reprint: Sun and Moon Guanghua bbs.fudan.edu.cn [FROM: 162.105.222.*]